Nicky's Undefeated Menu (Updated September 2025)
Welcome to Nicky's Undefeated, a vibrant new eatery located at 2316 Main St C in Tucker, GA. This restaurant brings authentic Philadelphia flavors to the South, and it's quickly becoming a local favorite. With its passionate origin story and focus on fresh ingredients, Nicky’s Undefeated offers a delicious array of sandwiches, salads, and sides that will leave your taste buds wanting more.
What sets Nicky's apart is their signature hoagies and cheesesteaks, crafted with generous portions of high-quality meats and toppings. The Italian Hoagie loaded with prosciutto and sharp provolone or the classic Rocky Balboa cheesesteak with melted cheese and marinara are must-tries that have received rave reviews from patrons. Customers often rave about the cheesesteak egg rolls, a unique twist on a classic, perfect for both a meal and a snack.
Another highlight is the customer service—the staff is welcoming and eager to share their knowledge about each dish. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Nicky’s Undefeated is a destination that promises a satisfying and hearty dining experience.
For those seeking nostalgia from the Philly area, the mouthwatering flavors and homemade sides—like the creamy ranch or spicy buffalo sauces—will hit home. Stop by for lunch or dinner and discover why this hidden gem is becoming everyone's new favorite spot!
Nicky's Undefeated - Appetizers
Buffalo Wings (6)
Tender chicken wings with your choice of sauce or dressing. Options include ranch, blue cheese, buffalo, garlic parmesan, and more.
US$14.50Buffalo Wings (12)
12 spicy chicken wings with options for sauce or dressing like Ranch, Blue Cheese, Garlic Parm, or extra celery.
US$25.00Garlic Parm Wings (6)
Garlic and Parmesan chicken wings. Choose from Naked, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Extra Sauce options or no dressing.
US$14.50Garlic Parm Wings (12)
Garlic parmesan flavor, choice of numerous dips and sauces including ranch, blue cheese, buffalo, or celery.
US$25.00Mozzarella Squares
Crispy breaded mozzarella squares with a side of marinara sauce.
US$13.00Pretzel Bites & Whiz
Soft and chewy pretzel bites served with creamy cheese dip.
US$12.00Pretzel Bites & Cooper
Soft, bite-sized pretzel pieces served with a side of creamy Cooper cheese dip.
US$12.00Chips & Whiz
Crispy tortilla chips served with creamy cheese dip.
US$10.00Chips & Cooper
Crispy tortilla chips served with a creamy cheese dip.
US$10.00Beef Nachos
Nachos with ribeye steak, fried onions, cheese whiz and Cooper American cheese. Side of jalapenos, pico de gallo and sour cream
US$16.00Chicken Nachos
Nachos with chicken, fried onions, cheese whiz and Cooper American cheese. Side of jalapenos, pico de gallo and sour cream
US$15.00Chicken Egg Rolls
2x Chicken Egg Rolls with onions and Cooper American cheese. Side of Hoagie Spread May on the side
US$12.00Beef Egg Rolls
2x Beef Egg Rolls with onions and Cooper American cheese. Side of Hoagie Spread May on the side
US$12.00Chicken Tenders (3) And Fries
Chicken tenders and fries, choice of tender sauce: ketchup, Buffalo, garlic Parmesan, ranch, blue cheese.
US$12.00Nicky's Undefeated - Non Alcoholic Drinks
Coke Bottle
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
US$4.50Sprite Bottle
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
US$4.50Diet Coke Bottle
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
US$4.50Coke Zero Bottle
The same great taste but with zero calories.
US$4.50Fanta Orange Bottle
Change up your routine with the bright, bubbly, fruity orange flavor.
US$4.50Powerade Blue Bottle
Replenish and rehydrate with this invigorating sports drink, typically featuring a vibrant blueberry flavor and essential electrolytes to support your active lifestyle.
US$4.50Choco Milk Bottle
A bottle of chocolate milk made with rich cocoa and smooth milk.
US$4.50Water Dasani Bottle
Enhanced with a proprietary blend of minerals to give it the clean, fresh taste you want from water.
US$4.00Mexican Coke Bottle
The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
US$5.00Mexican Sprite Bottle
A lemon-lime soda made with real cane sugar and bottled in Mexico.
US$5.00Ginger Ale Bottle
Carbonated soft drink with a distinct ginger flavor, typically enjoyed for its refreshing and slightly spicy taste.
US$4.50Dr. Pibb Bottle
An intensely flavored, refreshing, spicy cherry alternative to regular cola.
US$4.50Root Beer Bottle
Classic root beer in a bottle, typically featuring a sweet and creamy blend of sassafras and aromatic spices.
US$4.50Boylans Birch Beer
Boylan's birch beer: A handcrafted soda with a unique birch flavor, typically includes notes of wintergreen and vanilla, sweetened with cane sugar.
US$4.50Boylans Root Beer
Boylan's Root Beer: Handcrafted soda typically made with wintergreen, clove, and anise extracts, sweetened with cane sugar.
US$4.50Boylans Creme Soda
Boylan's creme soda: Made with cane sugar, this classic soda typically includes hints of vanilla extract, coffee, and chocolate for a uniquely refreshing taste.
US$4.50Boylans Black Cherry
Boylan's Black Cherry: Traditional hand-crafted American soda, featuring the deep and sweet flavor of black cherries.
US$4.50Boylans Orange
Boylan's Orange soda typically includes natural orange flavors and cane sugar for a classic, refreshing citrus taste.
US$4.50Boylans Ginger Ale
Boylan's ginger ale: A carbonated soft drink flavored with real ginger, offering a crisp and refreshing taste.
US$4.50Boylans Sparkling Lemonade
Boylan's sparkling lemonade: Freshly squeezed lemons with sparkling water, sweetened with cane sugar.
US$4.50Nicky's Undefeated - Desserts
Pistachio Ricotta Cake Slice
Nutty pistachio and creamy ricotta layers separated by sponge cake, decorated with crushed pistachios and a dusting of powdered sugar.
US$10.00Choco Hazelnut Temptation Slice
Layers of chocolate cake filled with hazelnut cream and crunch, finished with a smooth chocolate glaze.
US$10.00NY Cheesecake Slice
Creamy NY cheesecake on a graham cracker crust, typically topped with fresh berries and a light dusting of powdered sugar.
US$10.00Strawberry Cheesecake Slice
Creamy cheesecake topped with a sweet strawberry compote on a crumbly graham cracker crust.
US$10.00Tiramisu Cup
Classic Italian dessert made with ladyfingers soaked in coffee, layered with mascarpone cheese and dusted with cocoa.
US$10.00Nicky's Undefeated - Cheesesteaks (Half 6", Whole 12")
HALF Beef Cheesesteak
Beef Ribeye Cheese steak on a Liscios Roll. A half is 6 inches
US$15.00WHOLE Beef Cheesesteak
Beef Ribeye Cheese steak on a Liscios Roll. A Whole is 12 inches
US$27.00HALF Chicken Cheesesteak
Grilled Chicken Breast on a Liscios Roll. A half is 6 inches
US$15.00WHOLE Chicken Cheesesteak
Grilled Chicken Breast on a Liscios Roll. A whole large is 12 inches
US$27.00HALF Imposs Cheesesteak
Impossible meat, grilled burger style on a Liscios Roll. A half is 6 inches
US$15.00WHOLE Imposs Cheesesteak
Impossible meat, grilled burger style on a Liscios Roll. A large whole is 12 inches
US$28.00Nicky's Undefeated - Hoagies (Half 6", Whole 12")
HALF Italian Hoagie
6" roll, loaded with ham, mortadella (pistachio), prosciutto, genoa salami, hot capicola and sharp provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, Salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$14.50WHOLE Italian Hoagie
12" roll, loaded with ham, mortadella (pistachio), prosciutto, genoa salami, hot capicola and sharp provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, Salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$27.00HALF Roast Turkey Hoagie
Roasted turkey breast, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$14.50WHOLE Roast Turkey Hoagie
Roasted turkey breast, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$27.00HALF Ham & Cheese Hoagie
House ham, white American cheese. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$14.50WHOLE Ham & Cheese Hoagie
House ham, white American cheese. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$27.00HALF Turkey & Ham Hoagie
Roasted Turkey, house ham, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$14.50WHOLE Turkey & Ham Hoagie
Roasted Turkey, house ham, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$27.00HALF Maple Turkey Hoagie
Maple sweet turkey, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$14.50WHOLE Maple Turkey Hoagie
Maple sweet turkey, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$27.00HALF Veggie Hoagie
Broccoli Rabe, Roasted Red Peppers, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$12.75WHOLE Veggie Hoagie
Broccoli Rabe, Roasted Red Peppers, mild provolone. All Hoagies are built by default the Philly Philly Way which includes shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sliced onions, salt, pepper, oregano, olive oil and red wine vinegar.
US$22.75Nicky's Undefeated - Cutlets (Half 6", Whole 12")
HALF Rocky Balboa
6" Roll. Chicken Parm: mozzarella, parm, marinara
US$13.55WHOLE Rocky Balboa
12" Roll. Chicken Parm: mozzarella, parm, marinara,
US$24.00HALF Crazy Betty
6" Roll. Buffalo Chicken: mozzarella, buffalo sauce, she’s barely hot
US$13.55WHOLE Crazy Betty
12" Roll. Buffalo Chicken: mozzarella, buffalo sauce, she’s barely hot
US$24.00HALF Nick Foles
6" Roll. Chicken Breast hand pounded, breaded & fried to order. Built with broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze
US$13.55WHOLE Nick Foles
12" Roll. Chicken Breast hand pounded, breaded & fried to order. Built with broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze
US$24.50HALF Rizzo
6" Roll. Arugula, sharp provolone, tomato, nut free pesto, red wine vin, olive oil
US$13.55WHOLE The Rizzo
12" Roll. Arugula, sharp provolone, tomato, nut free pesto, red wine vin, olive oil
US$24.50Nicky's Undefeated - Fries & Chips
FRIES Regular
1/2" crinkle cut fries
US$5.00FRIES Old Bay
1/2" crinkle cut fries, old bay seasoning, it's a mid Atlantic classic.
US$6.00FRIES Wiz
1/2" crinkle cut fries, side of wiz cheese sauce
US$7.00FRIES Wiz Old Bay
1/2" crinkle cut fries, old bay seasoning, side of wiz cheese sauce
US$7.50FRIES Cooper
1/2" crinkle cut fries, side of cooper cheese sauce
US$7.00FRIES Cooper Old Bay
1/2" crinkle cut fries, old bay seasoning, side of cooper cheese sauce
US$7.50FRIES Pizza
1/2" crinkle cut fries, side of marinara sauce
US$7.00Herr's Chips - Plain
Classic, crispy potato chips typically seasoned with a light touch of salt.
US$4.00Herr's Chips - Old Bay
Crispy potato chips typically seasoned with a blend of Old Bay spices, including celery salt, black pepper, and paprika.
US$4.00Herr's Chips - Sour Cream And Onion
Ridged potato chips seasoned with a blend of sour cream and onion flavors.
US$4.00Herr's Chips - Honey BBQ
Crispy potato chips typically seasoned with a sweet and smoky honey BBQ flavor.
US$4.00Herr's Chips - Dill
Thin and crispy potato chips typically seasoned with a tangy dill flavor.
US$4.00Herr's Chips - Salt Vinegar
Crispy potato chips seasoned with a tangy blend of salt and vinegar.
US$4.00Nicky's Undefeated - Slices Of Pizza
Slice Cheese
A slice of pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and rich tomato sauce on a crispy crust.
US$6.00Slice Pepperoni
A slice topped with pepperoni, melted mozzarella, and savory tomato sauce on a crispy, thin crust.
US$7.00Slice Sausage
House-made Italian sausage, tomato sauce, and a blend of cheeses on a slice of pizza.
US$7.00Slice Chicken
Chunks of chicken on a classic pizza crust with cheese.
US$7.00Slice Buffalo Chicken
Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, blue cheese crumbles, and red onions on a pizza slice.
US$7.50Slice Broc Rabe (Veg)
Sauteed broccoli rabe on a hand-tossed crust with cheese.
US$7.50Mike's Hot Honey (Side)
Infused with chilies, this honey adds a sweet and spicy kick to your pizza.
US$2.00Nicky's Undefeated - Sides & Salads
Pasta Salad (5oz)
Rotini pasta mixed with cherry tomatoes, red onions, black olives, and bell peppers, dressed in a light vinaigrette.
US$6.00White Bean Salad (5oz)
Tender white beans mixed with diced red onions, fresh herbs, and a light vinaigrette.
US$6.00Side Romaine Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with sliced red onions, cherry tomatoes, shaved Parmesan, and a pepperoncini. Served with a side of dressing.
US$7.00Large Romaine Salad
Large romaine greens. Choice of Italian Dressing, Ranch, Blue Cheese, or No dressing.
US$16.00Hoagie SALAD (Italian Deli Meat)
Italian deli meat with choice of Italian Dressing, Ranch, Blue Cheese, or no dressing.
US$18.00Hoagie SALAD (Turkey)
Turkey hoagie salad. Fresh greens with choice of Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, or no dressing.
US$18.00Steak SALAD (Beef)
Mixed greens with steak. Choice of Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese dressing, or no dressing.
US$19.00Steak SALAD (Chicken)
Juicy steak or tender chicken atop a fresh salad. Choice of Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, or no dressing.
US$19.00Long Hots Italian Roasted X2
Roasted Italian long hot peppers, served as a side dish.
US$3.50Cherry Peppers (4oz)
A mix of sliced cherry peppers offering a tangy and mildly spicy flavor.
US$3.00Jalapenos (4oz)
Sliced, tangy jalapenos offering a spicy kick.
US$2.00Banana Peppers (4oz)
Sliced banana peppers, tangy and vibrant, perfect for adding a zesty kick to any meal.
US$2.00Hoagie Spread (4oz)
A tangy and spicy hoagie spread made with finely chopped peppers and seasonings.
US$2.00Roasted Red Peppers (4oz)
Tender roasted red peppers, sliced and served in a 4-ounce portion.
US$3.00Sweet Peppers (4oz)
Crisp sweet peppers sliced thin, perfect for adding a tangy crunch to any meal.
US$2.00Pickle Spears (2)
Crisp pickle spears, tangy and brined, served in pairs.
US$2.00Side Buffalo Sauce (3oz)
Buffalo sauce typically includes a blend of hot sauce and butter, offering a spicy and tangy complement to various dishes.
US$2.00Side Ranch
Creamy ranch dressing with herbs and spices.
US$1.00Side Blue Cheese
Creamy blue cheese dressing with a rich, tangy flavor, perfect for enhancing salads or as a dipping sauce.
US$1.00Side Marinara (3oz)
Rich tomato sauce with herbs and spices, perfect for complementing various dishes.
US$2.00Side Cooper Cheese Melted (3oz)
Creamy melted Cooper cheese, served in a 3oz portion.
US$3.00Side Whiz (3oz)
Smooth and creamy cheese sauce, perfect for dipping or topping.
US$3.00Extra Menu Picks
- The Blue Door Bottleshop & Beer Hall Menu 146 3rd Ave E, Hendersonville, NC 28792, United States
- Chick-fil-A Menu 915 Ann St, Montgomery, AL 36107, United States
- Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar Menu 3064 N Causeway Blvd, Metairie, LA 70002, United States
- Paik's Noodle Menu 677 120th Ave NE, Bellevue, WA 98005, United States
- Azteca Mexican Restaurants Menu 9738 N Newport Hwy, Spokane, WA 99218, United States
- City Winery Atlanta Menu Ponce City Market, 650 North Avenue NE, Atlanta, GA 30308, United States
- Office Lounge Menu 21 N Church St, Belleville, IL 62220, United States
- Rachels Mediterranean Grill Menu 2130 Walden Ave Suite 100, Cheektowaga, NY 14225, United States
- Pork Barrel BBQ Menu 2312 Mt Vernon Ave, Alexandria, VA 22301, United States
- Casa Ramos Mexican Restaurant Menu 2001 Main St, Red Bluff, CA 96080, United States